Top Line: The Senate is advancing permitting reform legislation that would be a body blow to public lands, endangered species, history, culture, clean air, clean water, and everything else we hold dear, and the public lands conservation community has never been weaker in the face of this threat.
Figure 1. Senator Martin Heinrich (D-NM), currently ranking member (highest in minority) and soon-to-be-chair of the Committee on Natural Resources of the US Senate. Heinrich is seeking to enact “permitting reform” legislation that is an existential threat to federal conservation laws. His faux status as a public lands champion gives political cover to fellow Senate Democrats to vote for this horrible bill. Source: More Than Just Parks.
I was planning to write next on the prospects for public lands conservation in the new 120th Congress (2027–2028) in light of the recent Democratic landslide election. I will soon, but we first must address legislation that may well be enacted into law during the current lame duck session of the present 119th Congress.
The Policy
“Permitting reform” legislation, officially called the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S.5653, 119th), would, according to The Wilderness Society:
• Lock in drilling and mining projects making it virtually impossible for future administrations to correct permits, even if they are unlawful;
• Weaken public participation in decisions affecting shared lands;
• Erode Tribal consultation and Tribal sovereignty while threatening sacred sites and cultural resources;
• Limit judicial review and make unlawful projects harder to correct in court; and
• Expand industry access to public lands without adequate safeguards.
In the name of speeding up permitting for renewables, BAAJA would effectively gut the Endangered Species Act, the National Forest Management Act, the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, and other statutes for all energy projects (including drilling, mining, and data centers) on public and private lands.
If you want to go deep to fully understand the legislation’s multitude of sins, Friends of the Earth has an informative web page on BAAJA. I will illuminate just one of the multitude. The Wilderness Society notes:
Sec. 1401 is the final nail in the coffin for threatened landscapes.
This section bans future administrations from taking any action on permitted projects on public lands, even when permits were approved unlawfully, except under extremely limited circumstances. This means effectively permanently entrenching drilling and mining projects on public landscapes that are currently targeted for shortsighted, corporate control. This includes the Greater Chaco Canyon region, Bears Ears National Monument and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness, the Arctic, all national public lands in the lower 48 that are currently available to oil and gas leasing, and increasingly, data center construction. Simply put, the “project certainty” provision in this bill would wedge the door open for these cherished landscapes to be permanently developed and exploited.
While entrenching existing sell-outs of treasured landscapes, this section also further emboldens the current administration to make reckless, unlawful decisions over the next two-plus years that hand over even more public lands to drilling and mining, while also restricting access to the courts and limiting the ability of the public and public interest organizations like TWS to challenge unlawful project decisions.
The Politics
Besides the usual card-carrying environmentalists, the opposition includes the likes of the NAACP, the Native American Rights Fund, and the Detention Watch Network.
Al Gore sums it all up well in a November 9, 2026, post on X:
There’s no doubt that we need to reform the way that clean energy projects are reviewed and permitted. But as it currently stands, [BAAJA] would be an extremely serious mistake, in my opinion, and would do far more harm than good. Given how this Administration has run roughshod over the environmental laws and protections that are currently in place, now is not the time to give the Trump administration freer rein to double down on fossil fuels—which is what President Trump would surely do. And after last week’s historic election, we will have a new Congress in January that can strike a far better balance.
Yet, there is significant support for BAAJA. Both the clean- and dirty-energy lobbies are in favor. Fans of data centers support it.
The Putrid
BAAJA has but four cosponsors, listed here with their League of Conservation Voters lifetime scores:
Senator Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV), 16%
Senator Mike Lee (R-UT), 7%
Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), 97%
Senator Martin Heinrich (D-NM), 94%
Lee is best known for his efforts to sell off public lands.
Whitehouse and Heinrich won’t sell off public lands, but they will happily sell out public lands, as is the case here. Whitehouse and Heinrich were both reelected in 2024 and will not potentially face the voters again until 2030.
Whitehouse has been a leader on climate change, and a most charitable analysis would say he wants to advance more low- or no-carbon energy projects to address climate change. BAAJA might do that, but it would do it as well for fossil-fuel projects. Anything President Trump signs, as he has indicated he would do with BAAJA, has only advanced and will only advance climate-killing and nature-destroying projects.
Of these four, I have the most scorn and disgust for Senator Heinrich. When he first ran for the Senate in 2012, I believe I sent him a check. That he led the Coalition for New Mexico Wilderness was enough for me. Today, I would like my money back. I commend to you the More Than Just Parks Substack takedown by Jim Pattiz entitled “Why Martin Heinrich Sold Out Public Lands.” You should subscribe!
The Pathetic
In the Senate, where 60 out of 100 votes are necessary to pass a bill, the public lands conservation community could scrape up only 25 senators to oppose BAAJA moving forward:
Alsobrooks (D-MD)
Baldwin (D-WI)
Bennet (D-CO)
Blunt-Rochester (D-DE)
Booker (D-NJ)
Cantwell (D-WA)
Duckworth (D-IL)
Durbin (D-IL)
Hassan (D-NH)
Hirono (D-HI)
Kaine (D-VA)
Kelly (D-AZ)
Lujan (D-NM)
Markey (D-MA)
Merkley (D-OR)
Murray (D-WA)
Padilla (D-CA)
Rounds (R-SD)
Sanders (I-VT)
Schiff (D-CA)
Smith (D-MN)
Van Hollen (D-MD)
Warren (D-MA)
Welch (D-VT)
Wyden (D-OR)
(List from Our Public Lands and Waters Substack, “Senate Democrats Advance BAAJA, Join Mike Lee and Trump’s Push for 'Pipelines, Mines, Power Plants, and Data Centers' on Public Lands.” You should subscribe!)
If one or both of your senators are not on the above list, they are not friends of public lands. In this case, our friends included a lone Republican, Senator Mike Rounds (R-SD). Given his League of Conservation Voters lifetime score of 8%, one can only assume he voted against advancing the bill because it isn’t horrible enough.
The Puny
That would be the public lands conservation community.
As I write this, a headline in the New York Times tells me: “Michael McCloskey Has Died. He Helped Make the Sierra Club a Political Force.” A Lane County, Oregon, native like me, Mike had a public lands conservation modus operandi quite different from, but complimentary to, mine.
In 1960, the legendary conservationist and then-Sierra-Club-executive-director David Brower discovered Mike and put him to work—at the request of US Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas—to prevent the logging of some old growth on the Wallowa-Whitman National Forest in northeast Oregon. Mike went on to serve as Brower’s trusted lieutenant until 1969, when the Sierra Club board of directors fired Brower. Half the staff left, and Mike became the executive director of a fractured organization.
Many matters led to Brower’s Sierra Club demise—he went on to found Friends of the Earth (where he was also fired) and then Earth Island Institute (which he structured in such a way as to preclude them ever having to fire him)—but the issue that brought Brower down at the Sierra Club was his flagrant disregard of the budget and of tax laws. To Dave, the Sierra was always more important than the Club. In contradiction of the Sierra Club’s IRS charitable tax status, he spent Sierra Club money lobbying Congress to stop dams and other crimes against nature.
The IRS revocation of the Sierra Club’s charitable tax status was the single best gift the Sierra Club ever received, and McCloskey made the most of it. Upon losing its charitable tax status, the Sierra Club gained the tax status of a social welfare organization. Soon McCloskey raised up a companion political action committee, legal defense fund, and charitable foundation to keep getting those foundation grants and large checks.
As the obit in the Times notes:
As executive director from 1969 to 1985, Mr. McCloskey helped to recruit more than 300,000 new members, opened dozens of local chapters and increased the group’s annual budget to $23 million from $3 million. The Sierra Club’s staff grew to 300 from 30 during the same period.
Mike McCloskey was not puny, nor was the Sierra Club in his day. However, in re BAAJA, the Sierra Club is taking a much weaker posture than all the other big national conservation organizations. Nonetheless, most of today’s public lands conservation organizations qualify as puny.
It is one thing to be rendered puny by the politics of the moment. It is quite another to do nothing to even try to no longer be puny.
The Possibility
The upside if BAAJA is enacted into law is that legions of conservation organization lawyers and other staffers won’t have much they can effectively do. Thus, they can be redeployed (or replaced) to center their organizations’ efforts to support and oppose candidates for elective office.
See Public Lands Blog posts “The Public Lands Conservation Movement: Mis-organized for Job #1” (March 2, 2018) and “While It Has Never Been Worse . . .” (June 16, 2025)
Bottom Line: Lobbying successes will only be possible if the public lands conservation community reorganizes itself to focus primarily on elections.